Villa demolition and rebuild: an alternative to renovation
More and more often, I find that prospective Clients who are interested in our working method are worried about how long they will have to wait, because they have not yet found the land to build on.
This is because, more often than not, they want to live in areas where the land has already been built on and there are no free building plots left.
In these cases, the solution I suggest is to buy an old villa and demolish it, so as to build a new one in its place that better suits your needs.
If you are in this situation too, I imagine this solution worries you, both for the time and for the cost. Am I right?
As for timing, from my past experience with renovations, I am convinced that renovating is far more demanding than demolishing and rebuilding.
Renovating a building is, in fact, like operating on a very elderly patient: it calls for far more care, with the risk that the result may still not be satisfactory.
During a renovation, complications always arise, and resolving them extends the works, which in turn delays completion and the handover of the house.
In addition, adapting old rooms to new needs often means altering the load-bearing structure and submitting a seismic compliance application to the local council, which frequently asks for additional documents that lengthen the process.
As for cost, the delays I have just described already push costs up in themselves.
But I would also like to talk to you about another financial aspect.
There is a belief that the cost of renovation added to the purchase price of an old house comes to the same as a new build.
In reality, the calculation often leaves out the cost of the unexpected issues that emerge along the way, and overlooks the fact that bringing a house up to the same seismic, acoustic and energy performance as a new one costs more than building new to that same performance.
Those who take the renovation route often realise all this when they are already in the middle of the works and, unable to turn back, are forced into compromises that cost time and leave them with a less comfortable house, different from the one they had imagined.
So why not give serious consideration to demolition and reconstruction?
Tax incentives also help, covering part of the expense: demolition and rebuild projects with a different building outline are now also classed as renovation work and can benefit from them.
Depending on the specific case, it is often possible to take advantage of Italian tax incentives such as the “Sisma Bonus” and the Eco Bonus, which can allow you to recover almost €100,000 for each property unit in the old house being demolished.
But what does demolition involve in terms of time and cost?
As a guide, demolition takes around 10–15 working days and costs around €20,000–40,000 to clear the plot (the cost depends very much on how the building is made: its position, materials and whether it has a basement). Compared with the total cost of the new project and the benefits you can gain, it is a manageable figure.
In conclusion, if you want a modern villa that is just as you like it, with every comfort, then for the same seismic, acoustic and energy performance it is more cost-effective to demolish and rebuild than to renovate.
If I have prompted you to think about the subject and you are now more inclined to follow my advice, I hope to see you soon to look at your situation and find the best solution for your needs.
In the villas we design on a plot that is already built on, demolition, permits and the new design are planned together, with time and costs written into the contract.
If you would like to know more about our working method, book a personal video call with no obligation and you can tell me about your specific needs.
If you would like to ask us something straight away, call us or message us on WhatsApp at +39 392 150 0378 and one of our Architects can already give you some initial answers.